Repair fixes a specific failure: a leaking base joint, a split louver, a loose panel, a cross knocked out of plumb by a storm. Most steeple calls end here, and a repair caught early is the cheapest steeple work there is.
Restoration brings the whole steeple back to sound condition while keeping its original structure and appearance. Framing repaired, flashing and joints renewed, the deck at the base recoated, cladding and trim restored, the exterior cleaned to the tip of the spire. On a historic church, restoration is almost always the right answer, and like-for-like materials keep the building’s character — and its eligibility for any historic designation — intact.
Replacement is for a steeple whose structure is too far gone to save, or whose base has to be rebuilt from underneath. The steeple is rigged and lifted off by crane, the base is repaired and made watertight while it is open, and the original steeple after repair — or a new one, often prefabricated — is set back and secured. It is a bigger day, but it is also the only way to fix the part of a steeple the steeple itself covers.
We make the call from evidence — photographs from inside the belfry and at the base, and probing of the framing — and we show the church board that evidence either way. We would rather restore a steeple than replace it, and we will tell you plainly when restoration would be money spent on a structure that cannot be saved.